AI Insight
This study examined the classification of PKD1 gene missense variants associated with Autosomal Dominant Polycystic Kidney Disease, the most common inherited kidney disorder. Researchers found that 89% of variants previously reported as disease-causing had to be downgraded to Variants of Unknown Significance when applying current classification standards, and commonly used computational prediction tools showed limited accuracy in distinguishing pathogenic from benign variants in this gene.
Why it matters
The findings highlight significant challenges in genetic diagnosis and counseling for polycystic kidney disease patients, as the majority of identified genetic variants cannot be definitively classified as disease-causing or benign. This uncertainty affects clinical decision-making, family screening, and potentially eligibility for emerging targeted therapies.
Understand the Science
⚠️ Preprint – Noch nicht peer-reviewed
Dieser Artikel wurde noch nicht von unabhängigen Experten begutachtet. Die Ergebnisse sind vorläufig und sollten mit Vorsicht interpretiert werden.
Purpose: Autosomal Dominant Polycystic Kidney Disease is the most common monogenic kidney disease and largely due to variants in PKD1. We aimed to assess pathogenicity evidence for PKD1 missense variants in disease databases and evaluate in silico pathogenicity prediction tool performance. Methods: PKD1 missense variants reported as pathogenic, likely pathogenic or likely benign were extracted from ClinVar and PKDB. Variants were re-classified using ACMG/AMP criteria to identify "truth sets" of pathogenic and benign variants. In silico scores were obtained from five tools (SIFT, PolyPhen-2, CADD, REVEL, AlphaMissense) and evaluated using established thresholds. A Receiver Operating Characteristic curve analysis was performed using the PKD1 variant truth sets. Results: 346/389 (89%) reported disease-causing missense variants in PKD1 were downgraded to Variants of Unknown Significance (VUS) using current classification criteria. Based on current thresholds, REVEL achieved the highest sensitivity of 62%, with specificity of 79%. AlphaMissense was the only tool not to misclassify any truth set variants, but many of the variant scores were between the pathogenic and benign thresholds. Conclusion: A large majority of PKD1 missense variants are classified as VUS with current pathogenicity criteria. Commonly used in silico tools, applied with established genome-wide thresholds, do not reliably distinguish pathogenic and benign missense variants in PKD1.